An elderly British Buddhist living in Australia is not the missing fugitive peer Lord Lucan, who disappeared in 1974 after murdering his family’s nanny, facial recognition experts have told MailOnline.
The mystery of Lucan’s whereabouts has intrigued detectives and the public for decades, and the latest claim that he is a British expat aged 87 living in a commune near Brisbane stoked the rumour mill once again.
The theory was proposed by the nanny Sandra Rivett’s surviving son, Neil Berriman, who tracked down the mystery pensioner in Australia and was convinced he was the man who killed his mother nearly 50 years ago.
But now MailOnline has seen an analysis of the same man’s photographs, compared with Lucan’s, prepared by a Home Office-approved team of facial recognition experts which definitively rules him out as Lucan.
The news lends extra weight to the man’s categorical denials that he was Lucan, issued by his carers at a Buddhist retreat in Brisbane.
Lord Lucan, who is accused of murdering nanny Sandra Rivett with a lead pipe in the basement kitchen of his Belgravia home, is believed to have died after evading authorities for years, and theories that he may be living in Australia have previously been touted, then debunked.
An elderly British Buddhist (left) living in Australia is not the missing fugitive peer Lord Lucan (right), who disappeared in 1974 after murdering his family’s nanny, facial recognition experts have told MailOnline
An algorithm was said to have matched photos of Lord Lucan, pictured with his wife Veronica, to an 87-year-old Buddhist living in Brisbane
Nanny Sandra Rivett was beaten to death with a lead pipe in 1974. Her body was found in the basement kitchen of Lord Lucan’s Belgravia house
Professor Hassan Ugail, who correctly identified the Russian agents behind the 2018 Salisbury Novichok poisonings
After a computer expert appeared to confirm the man as Lucan, Mr Berriman told the Mirror today: ‘I’ve spent nine years trying to prove this man is Lord Lucan. Now, with this new scientific information, the police must act. This isn’t emotion. It’s fact.’
But a new imagery report seen by MailOnline proves beyond doubt that the man was not Lucan.
It used detailed facial mapping techniques and was compiled by Dr Shelina Jilani of Home Office-approved Acumé Forensic, based in Leeds, whose experts frequently testify in court cases.
The experts were given a series of photographs of Lucan and the man in Australia by journalists from MailOnline’s sister organisation, The Mail on Sunday. The man was identified only as ‘Male A’.
Dr Jilani concluded: ‘The photographs of Lord Lucan bear sufficient features to eliminate the person from the reference images of Male A.’
She based her conclusions primarily on marked differences in the width of the nasal bridge between the two men, with Lucan having a narrow one and Male A having a wide one.
Another feature was the large protruding ears of Male A, which were not apparent on Lucan.
Dr Jilani added: ‘Factoring age related changes to morphology, there are features which are not comparable between [Lord Lucan] and Male A.’
It is understood that the conclusions were passed on to Mr Berriman, but he was unconvinced of the man’s innocence and subsequently approached the Mirror with his claims.
When confronted about his identity, the 87-year-old’s carers reportedly denied he was Lord Lucan.
Dr Shelina Jilani of Home Office-approved Acumé Forensic based her conclusions on the large protruding ears of Male A (right, 1 and 1a), which were not apparent on Lucan (left, 1 and 1a). She also noted the marked differences in the width of the nasal bridge between the two men, with Lucan (left, 2) having a narrow one and Male A (right, 2) having a wide one
The man suspected by Mr Berriman to be Lord Lucan lived in Nepal before moving to Australia in the 1980s.
He is understood to have used various names, including Derek and Adam, and apparently always carries his birth certificate with him.
At first he lived in Fremantle, near Perth, Western Australia. He then moved to the South Australian capital Adelaide and then onto a new home near Brisbane, Queensland.
There, he has been looked after by members of a Buddhist community and two young Englishmen are understood to act as his carers.
The elderly Buddhist was once a regular customer at a sushi restaurant in Brisbane.
Despite not working, he was reportedly never short of money.
The peer’s wife Veronica, who was also beaten in the brutal attack — at the hands of her husband, she claimed — died aged 80 after taking a cocktail of drink and drugs in 2017.
Mr Berriman sensationally claimed in January 2020 that Lord Lucan was alive and well and living as a Buddhist in Australia — claims that were dismissed as outlandish, despite police launching a probe into the matter.
Now Mr Berriman, who helped track down the mystery pensioner, has told The Mirror: ‘I’ve spent nine years trying to prove this man is Lord Lucan. Now, with this new scientific information, the police must act. This isn’t emotion. It’s fact.’
Professor Ugail’s analysis of the photographs included studying micro-millimetre measurements of spaces between facial features.
The expert said he has spent 20 years developing his algorithm, adding: ‘It has never been wrong.’
And The Mirror claims another company conducted tests on the photographs and came to the same conclusion.
A death certificate was issued by a High Court judge for Lord Lucan in 2016 following decades of speculation over the aristocrat’s whereabouts.
Lord and Lady Lucan with their son George, then aged three, taken from Lady Lucan’s photo album
It comes after a Mail investigation revealed how three Cluedo cards – including Colonel Mustard – were found in Lord Lucan’s abandoned car in the port town of Newhaven, East Sussex.
The Scotland Yard cold case review took place in 2004 when detectives examined sets of crime exhibits from the original murder investigation which had been hidden in a police storage facility. Its findings were not made public until recently.
Crucially, it found three cards were missing from a Cluedo set recovered from Lord Lucan’s home by murder squad officers in the wake of the attack — the same cards that were found in the peer’s abandoned car.
As anyone who has played Cluedo will know, the point of the game is to identify a murderer in a mansion full of guests after one has been killed.
The cards depict characters who might be the killer, as well as their potential weapons and the room in which the murder took place.
This gives rise to the most extraordinary question. Did the Eton-educated aristocrat model himself on Colonel Mustard and leave the three cards in his borrowed Ford Corsair as some sort of murder confession? Or did someone plant them there to frame him?
Along with Colonel Mustard (the murderer), the other two cards found in the car were the lead piping (murder weapon) and the hall (murder location).
The Mirror’s report was based on findings by Professor Hassan Ugail of the University of Bradford, using a computer logarithm.
But the new imagery interpretation report seen by MailOnline left no room for doubt.
Professor Hassan Ugail, described by the Mirror as a leading expert in the field of facial recognition, is credited with correctly identifying the Russian agents behind the 2018 Salisbury Novichok poisonings.
The computer scientist claims to have used an AI algorithm to run 4,000 cross-checks of seven photos: four of Lord Lucan, who vanished in 1974, and three of the frail Australian pensioner, The Mirror reported. He said: ‘This isn’t an opinion, it’s science and mathematical fact.’
It is alleged that the mystery pensioner moved from house to house across Australia before settling just outside of Brisbane.
The nanny’s surviving son Neil Berriman, left, blasted police in 2020 for not arresting a man living in an Australian Buddhist commune who he claimed is her killer. Right, Eton-educated Lord Lucan
Richard John Bingham, the 7th of Earl of Lucan, found himself at the centre of one of the world’s most enduring murder mysteries during the 1970s
A Colonel Mustard playing card, like the one found in Lord Lucan’s abandoned car, from a vintage Cluedo set
An intriguing new line of inquiry was pursued by police 18 years ago – an alleged sighting of Lord Lucan at a party in the Algarve weeks after the Rivett murder.
If Lord Lucan did indeed attend a party in Portugal, as a female witness tracked down and interviewed by the Met insisted, it would torpedo the theory that the gambling addict jumped to his death in the sea after dumping his borrowed car at Newhaven.
A former Scotland Yard detective said it was impossible to be definitive about many of the questions that still hang over the case.
But he added: ‘In my experience, the bodies of deceased people – including those who have drowned – almost always turn up. It is very difficult to conceal a body.
‘Of all the facts in the case, the one I am most certain of is that he didn’t die in this country.
‘I think he left or was helped to leave the country. If I was to put money on it, and given what I know, I think he went to Portugal alone or was helped to get there, and then transported to one of the Portuguese colonies such as Angola and Mozambique.’
Before the Met launched its last major review of the Lucan case in 2004, a senior detective penned a confidential report into the murder – a copy of which has been handed to Miss Rivett’s son Mr Berriman. It declares that the police did not have a single set of Lord Lucan’s fingerprints, nor any of his DNA for a profile.
A separate preliminary report was written by a detective in the Met’s Serious Crime Group in January 2002, and a copy of this has also fallen into the hands of Mr Berriman.
Its forensic account of his mother’s murder and what Lord Lucan did afterwards has never been published in the mainstream media. Dispassionate and detailed, it is both disturbing and compelling.
The information the report contains is based on original police files and evidence which would have been used had Lord Lucan ever stood trial for the killing.
Lady Annabel Birley, Zac Goldsmith’s mother, with Lord Lucan in an undated photo. The fate of the fugitive peer has captivated the imagination of the British public for decades
Lucan, as many know, was an Old Etonian with a taste for the high life. After finishing National Service in 1955, he raced power boats, drove an Aston Martin and flamboyantly left his job in a merchant bank to become a professional gambler.
The report refers to this: ‘He was associated with illegal gambling houses in Belgravia and Mayfair, until gambling was legalised in 1964, when he became a founder member of The Clermont Club. He was known by his gambling friends as ‘Lucky’.’
With his pretty young wife Veronica, he set up home in 1964 in a five-storey Victorian terrace house, where they had three children.
But Lady Lucan suffered poor mental health, notably post-natal depression, the marriage foundered and in 1973 Lucan moved to a flat nearby, where he was living at the time of the murder.
According to the police report, Lord Lucan was ‘devoted to his children’, and it proved a bitter blow when Lady Lucan later won an acrimonious custody battle for them.
It was around this stage, in September 1974, that Sandra Rivett became their nanny. On Thursday November 7 that year, Lady Lucan was watching television in her bedroom on the second floor of her home with her daughter Frances and the 29-year-old nanny. The other two children were in bed.
‘Thursdays were usually Sandra Rivett’s night off, but she had not gone out that evening,’ says the Met report. ‘At approximately 8.55pm Sandra Rivett asked Lady Lucan whether would she would like a cup of tea… and went down to the basement, where the kitchen was.
‘At about 9.15pm Lady Lucan went to the basement to see what was taking Sandra so long. She got to the top of the stairs that led to the basement and was surprised to see that there were no lights on.
‘She shouted ‘Sandra, Sandra’. Then she heard a noise from a room behind her and she was struck over the head a number of times. At this stage, she had not seen her attacker.
‘She fell to the ground and started to scream. Her attacker then put his gloved fingers down her throat and told her to ‘shut up’. She recognised the voice as Lord Lucan’s. A struggle ensued, during which Lady Lucan bit his fingers and grabbed his genitalia.’
At this stage her attacker gave up the fight. ‘He seemed to lose strength and Lady Lucan tried to talk to him. She asked him where Sandra was, he initially said she had gone out. He then said, ‘I’ve killed her, she came down first, if it had been you, you would have got it’.’
Lady Lucan managed to persuade her husband to go upstairs with her, so that she could clean her injuries. They went up to Lady Lucan’s bedroom.
Lord Lucan placed a towel on the bed and Lady Lucan lay on it. He went to use the bathroom, whereupon she ran out of the house to The Plumbers Arms nearby.
‘When she got into the pub,’ the report says, ‘she collapsed on the floor and screamed: ‘He’s murdered the nanny and he’s after the children”. The police and an ambulance were called.
‘The first officers on the scene spoke to Lady Lucan. She told them that the nanny had been murdered and she gave them her address. Lady Lucan was taken to St George’s Hospital, SW1.’
Police went to the family home and forced the door open. According to the Met dossier, officers discovered Sandra Rivett’s body in a canvas United States mailbag in the basement.
There were two separate ‘seats’ of attack, the report says. The first in a small well of the stairs on the ground floor by the hall.
Here, the carpet was ‘heavily stained with blood and there were directional splashes of blood on the wall and ceiling’. There were also smears of blood on the walls and on a door that opened to the basement.
The Daily Mail of November 12, 1974, on the ongoing murder mystery
What happened to Lord Lucan, and is he still alive? The four most likely theories about his disappearance
Theory one: Lucan drowned himself off Newhaven after murdering the nanny
Lord Lucan’s friend James Wilson, who gambled with him at London’s Clermont Club, said five years ago he believes Lucan killed himself after murdering Ms Rivet.
Mr Wilson said he filled his pockets with rocks and stones before jumping off his scuppered speedboat in Newhaven Harbour just hours after the killing.
He told the Telegraph in 2015: ‘I believe that when he realised he had killed the nanny, the remorse, guilt and panic led him to commit suicide. He must have realised he only had two options open to him; hand himself in or kill himself. Having lost the gamble he chose the latter’.
In an ITV documentary before her death in 2017, Lady Lucan said she believed Lord Lucan had jumped off a ferry shortly after the killing.
‘I would say he got on the ferry and jumped off in the middle of the Channel in the way of the propellers so that his remains wouldn’t be found’.
Theory 2: Lucan fled to Africa – and lived there quietly until he died in 2000
Shirley Robey, who worked for Lucan’s casion owner John Aspinall claimed in 2012 she overheard conversations with Lucan’s friend Sir James Goldsmith, father of Zac Goldsmith in the early 1980s.
She said the pair said Lucan was in Africa, adding: ‘ I knew he was hiding, I knew he was in Africa, I knew we were hushing it up. I knew he’d fallen out with his wife and I knew it was a major secret but for whatever reason I didn’t appreciate there had been a murder until some years later. If I’d have known, I think I would have handled things quite differently. In fact I know I would have done’. She claims she heard he died in 2000, in his mid-60s.
Theory 3: Lucan shot himself and was fed to a tiger called Zorra in a Kent zoo
Philippe Marcq, another of Lucan’s casino friends, told MailOnline previously that friends of the Earl disposed of his body at Howletts zoo near Canterbury, set up as a private zoo in 1957 by John Aspinall, another friend of Lucan’s.
Mr Marcq said he was told story by Lucan’s friend Stephen Raphael. It is claimed a pistol was offered to Lucan who took it, went into a room on his own and shot himself dead and the friends removed his body.
Mr Marcq said: ‘I was stunned when Stephen told me this. But I believed what he told me 100 per cent’.
Aspinall’s mother, Lady Osborne, the grandmother of former Chancellor George Osborne, apparently told police: ‘The last I heard of him, he was being fed to the tigers at my son’s zoo.’
Police are said to have subsequently descended on Howletts, where a contemptuous John Aspinall told them: ‘My tigers are only fed the choicest cuts — do you really think they’re going to eat stringy old Lucky?’
Theory 4: Lucan didn’t commit the murder – and was helped to flee by his circle
Lucan’s brother, Hugh Bingham defended the peer’s innocence until he died in South Africa.
He always claimed he in fact went into hiding after Rivett’s death, which he was innocent. He said: ‘I have always believed he didn’t commit murder/ He had no choice but to flee in the face of cruel allegations. The police inquiry was compromised from the start. There is significant evidence of the existence of an unknown man at the scene – is he known to police?’
The second ‘seat’ of attack was in the basement, where there were pools of blood at the foot of the stairs and blood on the wall.
They found a piece of heavily bloodstained lead piping wrapped in adhesive tape, and a light bulb on a chair – it appeared to have been removed from the basement light. Presumably the nanny was attacked in the dark.
But what happened to the fugitive after the attack?
Mrs Madeleine Florman lived some 200 yards round the corner from Lady Lucan’s home in Lower Belgrave Street. She was in bed at approximately 10.30pm on the night of the murder when she heard someone persistently ringing her front door bell.
She chose not to answer the door. Then her phone rang. A male voice said ‘Madeleine, I know that’s you.’ The speech was slurred and the man put the phone down. She believed it was Lord Lucan, according to police.
At approximately 10.45pm, Lord Lucan’s mother Kaitlin received a phone call from a public phone box. It was her son. He told his mother that there had been the most awful catastrophe at his wife’s home. He said he had seen a light on in the basement and had interrupted a fight there.
He told her that Veronica (Lady Lucan) had been hurt and the nanny had been hurt worse. He asked her to contact his brother-in-law Bill Shand-Kydd and told her to go to his wife’s house immediately and get the children.
She did just that. The report takes up the story: ‘At 12.30am Kaitlin Lucan received a second call from her son. He enquired about the welfare of his children. She told him that the police were with her and suggested that he should speak to them.
‘He told her that he would speak to them in the morning. Kaitlin Lucan thought he sounded much calmer during the second phone call, than in his first.’
Susan Maxwell-Scott was married to a gambling friend of Lord Lucan. On the night of the murder, she had gone to bed at her home in Uckfield, East Sussex.
At about 11pm she heard the front door bell, looked out of the window and saw that it was Lord Lucan.
She let him into the house and noticed that he was slightly dishevelled and that the upper right leg of his trousers was wet.
‘Mrs Maxwell-Scott asked Lord Lucan what was wrong. He told her that he had had an ‘unbelievably nightmarish experience’,’ according to the 2002 police report.
‘He then told her that he had been walking past the family home and saw a man attacking his wife in the basement. He explained that he went into the house… Whilst he was there he slipped in a pool of blood and the man who had been attacking his wife ran off. He said that his wife was covered in blood and that the nanny had been killed and was in a sack.’
Mrs Maxwell-Scott told detectives Lord Lucan he had panicked and left the house after finding himself also drenched in blood.
‘Lord Lucan then took some writing paper, a pen and some envelopes from Mrs Maxwell-Scott,’ continues the report. ‘He wrote two letters to Bill Shand-Kydd (his brother in law) and left the letters with Mrs Maxwell-Scott. Her daughter posted both of them the following morning.
‘At approximately 1.15am, Lord Lucan left Mrs Maxwell-Scott, she thought that he was driving a dark saloon vehicle.
‘Mrs Maxwell-Scott did not report Lord Lucan’s visit to the police. It was only discovered after Bill Shand-Kydd informed the police that he had received two letters.’
Enquiries revealed that before the murder, in late October, Lucan had approached a gambling fiend, Michael Stoop. He asked Stoop whether he could borrow his Ford Corsair. Stoop didn’t ask any questions and lent it to him.
‘From statements taken from two of the residents of Norman Road, Newhaven, Sussex, it can be deduced that the Ford Corsair was parked in this street between 5am and 8am on November 8,’ says the report.
In its boot, the police found a length of lead piping wrapped in adhesive tape – just like the murder weapon at the crime scene. Blood smears and ‘tangled head hair’ were also found in the car.
But what about the two letters, both of which were bloodstained? They ‘were received by Bill Shand-Kydd on November 9 and he took them to the police’.
In the first, Lucan claimed he had interrupted a fight at Lower Belgrave Street. He also said the circumstantial evidence against him was ‘very strong’ and that Veronica would say he ‘did it’ so he will ‘lie ‘doggo’ for a bit’.
The second letter was titled ‘Financial Matters’ and talked of a sale at Christie’s auction house that would satisfy bank overdrafts. It listed a number of financial institutions that should receive the proceeds, adding that ‘the other creditors can get lost’. This letter was signed ‘Lucky’.
Lady Lucan in 2017 (left), and with Lord Lucan before they married on November 20 1974
A number of Lucan’s associates had described him as having financial problems and said he had come to them to borrow money. He had large debts in relation to his child custody battle and was drinking heavily and gambling regularly.
The post-mortem examination of Rivett’s body showed that she had received injuries to her head, bruising to her shoulders, arms and hands. She had cuts and bruising to the eyes consistent with a ‘slap or a punch’. The cause of death was ‘blunt head injuries’. It concluded that the lead piping found at the murder scene could have caused these injuries.
Lady Lucan had five lacerations of the skull and forehead. They were deep and jagged and if she had received these wounds to the rear of her head, they may have been fatal. She also had lacerations on the inside of her mouth.
By any standards, it was a brutal murder and could easily have been a double killing.
An inquest into the death of Sandra Rivett was held in March 1975. In his absence, the jury returned the verdict: ‘Murder by Lord Lucan.’ The case was committed to the Crown Court for trial, which never took place.
In the five decades since, there have been dozens of supposed sightings of him in various locations in the UK and around the world – all documented in statement form and followed up by the Met.
Officially the case remains ‘open’ but plans for a full-scale new investigation were blocked in 2004 by senior Yard commanders, who questioned what it would achieve and at what cost.
Lord Lucan’s life and grisly legacy
The Daily Mail from November 1974 as police hunt for Lucan’s body at sea and his estranged wife Lady Lucan leaves a police station after saying he was guilty of the murder – and trying to kill her
December 18 1934: Richard John Bingham is born in London into an aristocratic family with connections to Ireland.
1955: He got a job with a small merchant bank, William Brandts, for £500 a year.
1960: He retires having won £26,000 – around £600,000 in today’s money – over two nights playing ‘chemin de fer’ at a gambling party run by John Aspinall.
1963 Marries Veronica Duncan – the couple have three children
1964 Becomes an earl after the death of his father, the 6th Earl of Lucan
1972 Their marriage collapses and Lucan moves out of the family home at 46 Lower Belgrave St, London. He loses a custody battle and accrues gambling losses
November 7 1974 The children’s nanny Sandra Rivett is found dead. At 9.45pm, Lady Lucan, in great distress, burst into the Plumber’s Arms, the pub near her home in the exclusive area of Belgravia in central London.
With blood streaming from several wounds on her head, she cried: ‘Help me, help me, help me! He’s in the house! He’s murdered my nanny!’
Lady Lucan, who was estranged from her husband, told police her estranged husband had killed their nanny and tried to kill her. Police found the couple’s three children asleep in their beds, unharmed, and when they went to the basement they were greeted by a macabre scene.
The basement lightbulb had been removed, but in the semi-darkness, officers made out a pool of blood with a man’s footprint in it, a blood-stained length of lead piping and a mailbag containing a body.
November 14 1974: Lucan’s car is found abandoned near Newhaven and police begin searching for his body at sea after his speedboat was found scuppered.
June 1975 Lucan is named as Ms Rivett’s killer at the inquest into her death.
1999 His family is granted probate over Lord Lucan’s estate, but no death certificate is issued.
2016: A court issued a ‘presumption of death’ certificate for Lord Lucan, a ruling that cleared the way for the couple’s son, George Bingham, to become the 8th Earl of Lucan.